Tuesday, 15 December 2015

No quick fixes left as global economy battens down for the Fed’s first rate hike

 
Global policymakers might like to think they walked on water with quantitative easing, but, as Japan has shown over recent decades, once deflation gets embedded, economic miracle cures are no easy solution. The latest downturn in energy and commodity markets is another unsettling sign that the major economies and global financial markets are heading for another deflation wave and tougher times ahead.

Two decades on from Japan’s first foray into QE, the nation’s leaders are still battling to wrestle the economy from the grip of chronic recession risks and deflation dangers - and they remain a long way off from normalising policy. It has been a long hard battle and it is not over yet.

There must be many central bankers from leading industrial countries suffering acute night terrors, wondering how to retreat from zero interest rates and the explosion of QE-led bond buying since 2008 that has left them with an unfathomable puzzle. That is, how to reduce the dependency on super easy monetary accommodation without damaging growth?

This week, the US Federal Reserve will attempt to do just that when it finally lifts interest rates after seven long years at zero per cent. The Fed has decided the time is ripe to begin the return journey to neutral interest rates somewhere around the 3 to 4 per cent mark.
 
The second leg of ‘mission impossible’ comes later on when the Fed starts disposing of its huge 4-1/2 trillion dollar stockpile of QE assets. There is no date fixed for that yet, but the Fed probably wants to put it off for as long as possible. It could wreak a terrible toll on the global economy and world financial markets.

The world can do without more turmoil. Since 2008, the global financial crisis has already been through three disastrous phases. The credit crunch in the US and UK, Europe’s sovereign debt crisis and more recent emerging market mayhem have all left global confidence in a precarious state. There may be no easy way back from a ‘fourth wave’.

When the Fed eventually pares back its over-bloated balance sheet, global liquidity will feel the pinch. So too will global asset markets which have been kept afloat by vigorous QE pump-priming for the last seven years. Investors who have indulged in cheap, easy leverage will suffer severe withdrawal pains as rates go up and liquidity is squeezed.

There will be no easy fix. Markets are already bracing for the dawn of tighter money this week, while the global economy is showing worrying signs of fatigue. The US and UK economies are losing vital momentum, the euro zone is mostly struggling, China is slowing down and Japan has just avoided another technical recession. Emerging economies remain at risk.

The continuing collapse in global commodity and oil prices reveal disturbing cracks in the world economic outlook. The drop in crude oil prices to the lowest levels since 2008 is symptomatic of a growing shortfall in global demand as economic activity slows up.

The aftermath of the global financial crisis is still being felt. Balance sheet restructuring, debt-deflation and austerity cutbacks are casting dark shadows over world economic confidence. Consumer, business and investor optimism remains skittish and the spectre of rising US interest rates could be the tipping point for another major market meltdown.

The Fed is clearly being blinded by glowing US employment numbers, with the US jobless rate back to pre-crisis levels. But it is important to remember unemployment is a lagging not leading indicator. There are still weak links in the US economy and the global backdrop remains deeply unsettled.
 
World trade has already shrunk 15 per cent from levels a year ago. Global growth projections continue to be downgraded by leading forecasters like the IMF and OECD. World economic sentiment remains balanced on a knife edge.
 
If the Fed miscues and global confidence goes into knee jerk reverse, there is little to stand in the way. The world’s policymakers have run out of easy options. The global economy is building resistance to new QE initiatives and there is precious little fiscal slack left while governments continue to cut budget deficits and slash debt.

Global equity, credit and bond markets could easily be swept up into the mother of all ‘taper tantrums’ if the risk-off mentality gets a firmer grip. The danger is global policymakers will end up hapless bystanders without a cure.

Wednesday, 9 December 2015

Global investors losing patience and faith in the euro



There was once a time when the euro was one of the world’s most favoured currencies, the must-have foreign exchange asset sought by traders, investors and currency reserve managers. It is no longer the case. In recent years the currency has fallen from grace and become more of a pariah with international investors.

Last week’s news that China’s yuan will be included for the first time in the International Monetary Fund’s basket of reserve currencies is likely to deal another blow to the euro’s waning appeal. It will lead to a re-jigging of global investment preferences away from the euro’s failing fundamentals towards the yuan’s growing allure, backed up by much mightier economic and financial resources.
The euro is plagued by deep rooted problems. The European Central Bank is struggling to jump-start faster recovery in the euro area and trying to prevent a slide into deeper deflation crisis. There are mounting credibility issues too with signs of growing internal dissent evident within the ECB’s ranks over its stimulus strategy. And the euro could be hit hard next week when the US Federal Reserve finally hikes rates for the first time in a decade.

It is not looking encouraging. Investors could be deserting the euro in droves, putting a test of parity versus the resurgent US dollar squarely in the frame in the coming weeks.

Nobody wants a currency that fails to protect intrinsic value and loses investor confidence. The euro might have enjoyed a sharp 3 per cent rebound in the wake of the last week’s ECB policy decision, but it was nothing more than a short-covering rally, sparked by investors being wrong-footed by misleading official hints in the lead up to the meeting.

For weeks, the central bank had stoked up expectations that it would deliver a much more effective stimulus package, comprising lower rates with an accelerated quantitative easing programme, releasing much-needed extra cheap cash into the economy.

But last week’s ECB measures fell well short of expectations. The market had hoped for more than the meagre 10 basis point ECB deposit rate cut to -0.3 per cent and the bare-minimum six month extension of the 60bn euro monthly bond buying programme. The disappointment has triggered concerns about a fierce internal row raging inside the ECB.

Germany’s Bundesbank has openly criticised the risks of QE overkill and warned that further monetary accommodation is unnecessary. It is a dangerous rift that casts serious doubts about future strategy and not good news for the currency if policymaking stays divided.

There is a very real danger the ECB will never fully get on top of the crisis, if Germany blocks future policy initiatives. With the ECB’s asset purchase programme already extended to March 2017, the euro will in any case stay chronically depressed for a long while yet.

The inclusion of China’s yuan into the IMF’s basket of reserve currencies, due to take place in October 2016, will be another factor working against the euro in the long run. The euro’s current weighting in the IMF’s Special Drawing Rights basket will be cut to 30.93 per cent from 37.4 per cent. The yuan’s weighting will enter the SDR basket with a 10.92 per cent share.

This is bound to affect relative asset allocation preferences among the world’s central banks as currency reserve managers begin to rebalance investments in favour of the yuan to reflect the new SDR weightings. The yuan looks set to enjoy a honeymoon period in the next few years and mainly at the euro’s expense.

From a standing start in 1999, when the euro was first introduced, the single currency enjoyed a surge in demand with its share of world foreign exchange reserves rising to a 28 per cent peak in 2009. But, in recent years, its popularity with reserve managers has been badly blighted by the euro zone crisis and unsettling market volatility. The euro’s share of world reserves has since fallen back to 2002 levels around 20 per cent and the decline looks set to continue.

With the euro losing investor confidence and its currency fundamentals on the slide, central bank reserve managers will continue to diversify away. The US dollar will prosper thanks to its rising interest rate appeal. So too will the yuan, reflecting its economic and financial strengths.


There seems little the ECB can do to stop the rot. Global investors have lost patience and faith in the euro.


Monday, 30 November 2015

Euro about to be caught in the ECB and Fed’s crossfire


Over the next fortnight, global markets have a major battle on their hands, dealing with the consequences of two of the world’s leading central banks moving policy in opposite directions.

This Thursday, the European Central Bank should put monetary stimulus into overdrive. While in a fortnight’s time, US Federal Reserve policy will hit the brakes for the first time in a decade.

There will be casualties along the way. Whenever any policy backdrop looks muddled, markets feel unsettled. Global equities, bonds and currency markets are all likely to feel greater fall-out from conflicting policy crosswinds. 

The biggest changes will be felt in relative asset shifts. The effect of the ECB stepping into super-stimulus mode will favour European equity markets over the US. The Fed launching off into tighter policy will also spell the end of the road for the 35-year bull market for US bonds and sharpen the market’s appetite for safe haven German government debt.

With US interest rates heading higher, at the same time that euro zone rates are turning increasingly negative, sentiment towards the euro will be hit hard. And if the ECB hits the panic button on easing, it will quickly tip the euro below parity against the US dollar. The last time this happened the euro sank to a post-EMU low of 0.8230. There is a lot at stake.

The ECB have already hinted at more aggressive easing this week to bolster recovery prospects and stop the economy slipping into a worse deflation crisis. Talk has centred on the chances of another rate cut, plus staggered penalty charges on banks hoarding cash rather than lending. Meanwhile, more accelerated bond buying is expected under the ECB’s quantitative easing programme.

Markets can hardly be blamed for thinking there is more than a hint of desperation in the air – never a good omen for currency stability. If the ECB is intent on opening up the monetary accelerator to full throttle then the euro is in deep trouble.

With the Fed set to move US monetary policy onto a less accommodative footing in two week’s time, the euro has even more to worry about. The market is not only threatened by short term rate tightening risks, but also what happens longer term when the Fed begins to unwind its huge cache of QE assets, stockpiled over the last seven years. Now worth around $4.5 trillion, it is a huge load for the markets to re-absorb.

The Fed is desperately trying to get its message across about a ‘gentle’ process of policy normalisation ahead. But there is no safeguard for a market fretting about a future Fed funds rate possibly heading back over 1-2 per cent, with all the negative connotations for higher US Treasury yields, especially once the Fed’s ‘great unwind’ of QE assets begins in earnest.

The Fed believes it can soothe market expectations, but once perceptions for higher rates and yields are out of the bag, the bullish mood for bonds will quickly evaporate and the bear market will be back. Ten year US Treasury yields have already touched 3 per cent in the last two years, within easy reach of the current 2.25 per cent once market optimism breaks down.

Longer term, 10-year US bond yields returning back to pre-crisis levels over 5 per cent cannot be ruled out, especially if the Fed has its eye on hitting interest rate neutrality closer to 3-4 per cent, with a dramatically slimmed down balance sheet in its quest for monetary ‘normality’.

Rising US bond yields are great news for the dollar, but bad for the euro, especially with so much of the benchmark euro zone government curve already steeped in negative territory. With the 10-year German-US bond spread looking deeply unfavourable at minus 175 basis points right now, the euro looks set to suffer the consequences as investors switch to higher yielding markets.

The close market correlation between the two-year US-German bond spread and the euro suggests the euro/dollar exchange rate is positioned for a dive through parity very soon. Once parity breaks, the bears will swoop and the feeding frenzy will intensify.

Nothing is standing in the way. The Fed looks determined to hike rates and the ECB seems committed to raising the super-stimulus stakes. Official benign neglect towards the euro appears to be taking over.


It is a risky strategy, but the ECB is pinning its hopes on a much weaker euro to resurrect the recovery and rekindle inflation.





Monday, 2 November 2015

Britain’s boom is running on empty and ready to stall

Conspicuous success can sometimes be very superficial and fail close scrutiny. Outside observers could easily envy the UK’s economic record over recent years, boasting a blistering growth rate, plunging unemployment and a booming housing market. Britain was the fastest growing of the biggest developed economies last year, so it is hard to imagine much of a problem.

But Britain is sitting on a time-bomb. The economy looks in poor shape to deal with the onset of slower global growth. Recession risks are rising, deflation remains deeply embedded and Britain’s yawning trade and budget gaps leave little scope for possible policy antidotes.

Longer term, the picture looks unsettling. Two potential structural shocks lie in wait. The UK government is set on a collision course with Brussels over its EU membership, which could eventually lead to a damaging exit from Europe. Meanwhile, independence pressures are still bubbling up in Scotland. Both events could inflict cataclysmic future blows on the economy.

Credit rating agencies are watching from the sidelines and are not impressed. Britain’s highly-regarded international reputation and top-notch credit ratings are at stake. UK financial markets and the British pound have a lot to lose.

Having been the pin-up poster economy in recent years, the UK now looks vulnerable. The UK economy lost momentum in the third quarter with quarterly growth slowing to 0.5 per cent in the past three months, compared with 0.7 per cent in the previous quarter.

A sharp fall in Britain’s bellwether construction industry was the main culprit for the slowdown. But another tell-tale sign of trouble ahead was a 7.1 per cent slump in steel production in the third quarter. Even before the recent round of closures in the British steel industry, the slump in global steel demand has been a worrying trend.

It is a precursor to troubling times ahead for UK manufacturers. As a major trading nation Britain is already feeling the pinch of slower global growth, with the strong pound compounding the problem as dwindling export competitiveness continues to hit demand for UK goods and services.

Early signs of slowdown are starting to show up in the domestic economy. Despite the boom in UK house prices, British mortgage approvals fell in September for the first time in four months and retail sales growth is starting to soften with consumer confidence dampened by deepening uncertainty about the domestic and international outlook.

The trouble is that UK policy is firing on blanks right now. UK interest rates are already at zero per cent, while the government remains intent on balancing its budget books in the next few years. UK policymakers would be powerless to act in the event of a sudden downturn in the economy, without a major policy U-turn.

In the last two years, sterling’s value against a range of currencies has risen as much as 15 per cent, buoyed up by strong capital inflows, nearly the monetary equivalent of a 5 per cent rise in short term interest rates. The Bank of England has already achieved its wished-for monetary tightening by default. Its aim to hike rates soon simply piles extra pressure on the economy

Bigger risks lie ahead. If British Prime Minister David Cameron fails in his quest to secure a better EU membership deal for the UK, the country could be heading into a dangerous referendum on a possible exit from the single market. With recent opinion polls showing the nation split right down the middle on the matter, it could have devastating results.

It could spark a major flight of banks, businesses and foreign capital out of the country, losing a huge chunk of productive capacity from the British economy. It would also precipitate another independence push by Scotland, risking an extra 10 per cent lost from UK output. Britain could end up in deep depression, so it is no surprise the rating agencies are taking a downbeat view.

Market reports suggest currency traders are still extremely upbeat on the pound based on views that the BOE will stage an early rate hike next year. But markets have short memories and forget too easily that sterling is ‘banana-skin’ currency that is prone to major slip-ups.

Sterling bulls may be on the warpath right now, but a delay in the BOE’s plans to tighten policy in 2016 could trigger a dramatic reversal in sentiment.


Longer term, if Britain is heading into an economic backwater, confidence in the pound would be a major casualty.





Monday, 24 November 2014

Concerted action by world leaders boosts recovery hopes



There is more than a hint of possible policy co-ordination in the air. Countries very rarely act in concert when it comes to major policy changes, but last Friday saw some good clues that global policymakers are coming together to help repair the global economy.

The Eurozone threw its doors wide open to new monetary policy initiatives, Japan called snap elections to get a fresh mandate for more policy stimulus and China cheered the markets with a surprise rate cut. The fact that it all happened on the same day suggests something more than serendipity is at play.

Fear can sometimes be a very powerful motivator and the dread of another global downturn has probably spurred world policymakers into action to boost recovery. Global economic summits generally tend to be long on promises and short on delivery, but the spectre of another world recession might have been enough to tip the balance at the recent Brisbane G20 world leaders’ summit. Their pledge to boost global output by an extra $2 trillion over the next four years, combined with last Friday’s events, suggests a new watershed in policy efforts to get the world economy working faster again. Global markets could have something really tangible to cheer about.

The Eurozone has given markets plenty to worry about in recent years as one of the weakest links in the global recovery chain. But that may be changing very soon. On Friday, European Central Bank President Mario Draghi ramped up the rhetoric that unless the Eurozone economy improves soon, the bank must do everything in its power to raise inflation and inflation expectations and quickly. In other words, Draghi is giving his blessing for full-blown quantitative easing (QE) – by buying bonds and printing money to fast-track the Eurozone economy into much better health, stronger growth and fuller employment. It marks a major sea-change for the ECB and boosted investor hopes for a potentially happy ending. The markets loved it with the benchmark German DAX share index ending Friday’s session up a massive 2.6%.

Japan is also picking up the baton for change after the economy slipped back into a shock recession in the third quarter. Japan’s Prime Minister Shinzo Abe dissolved parliament’s lower house last Friday for a snap election in December. The markets see this as good news as it should pave the way for extra stimulus measures to boost the chances of faster Japanese growth ahead. Critically, the second leg of an unpopular sales tax, which has clobbered consumer spending in the last two quarters, has been put on hold. The Bank of Japan will continue to bear the brunt of recovery efforts through hyper-easy monetary policy and the next government will need to conjure up more fiscal stimulus to pump up demand. As long as a return to faster growth remains the over-riding priority it should be good news for Japanese stocks.

China joined in Friday’s day of action too, surprising the markets with a cut in interest rates to boost the economy as it struggles to overcome its slowest expansion in a quarter of a century. The interest rate cut followed disappointing purchasing mangers’ data which showed manufacturing activity stalling and getting dangerously close to contraction. Slower growth, lacklustre domestic credit expansion and the cooling property market mean that this rate cut is unlikely to be an isolated incident. The case for further rate cuts extending into next year will continue to build. The pressure on the Chinese authorities to deliver more growth and jobs is not going to go away any time soon.

Meanwhile, in the background, the US and UK are doing their bit for global reflation efforts – by doing nothing on normalising super-easy monetary policy just yet. While the rapid pick-up in growth and employment prospects in both economies would normally dictate quicker policy reversals, the US Federal Reserve and the Bank of England both seem reasonably content to delay tightening for now to allow conditions for sustainable recovery to consolidate longer term. And while the Fed and the BOE continue to hold fire on higher rates, it is reassuring for global equity markets to know that the US and UK are keeping a mindful eye on the bigger picture and helping to propping up global GDP in the process.

The global recovery may seem on tenterhooks right now but there is no reason for markets to lose heart. If global policymakers are starting to pull together and stepping up efforts to boost world growth in a more co-ordinated way, the chances of securing a recovery capable of enduring a lot longer should improve dramatically.

It would be a watershed that could extend the five year old rally in global stocks for a few more years to come.

Reprinted by courtesy of South China Morning Post - 24 November 2014


Thursday, 20 November 2014

Avoiding a hard landing for euro economy isn't rocket science


Europe can achieve great success when it tries. The European Space Agency has just managed to plant a robotic lander on a tiny comet after a four billion mile journey through space. It’s a scientific achievement that could help us unlock some of the deepest secrets of the universe.

European economic policymakers on the other hand cannot hit a barn door with a shotgun. That means the odds of a hard landing for the euro zone economy are rising, not falling some six years after the global financial crisis first erupted.

Policymakers appear paralyzed by the after-effects of 2008-2009 crisis and 2011-2013 twin recessions. Weak economic confidence, high unemployment, grueling fiscal austerity policies and growth-sapping debt deflation are big problems, but they are not insoluble.

If Europe’s politicians had the same kind of focus as their top scientists, it’s hard to believe that we’d have suffered the half-hearted and mis-directed reflation efforts that have kept the euro zone economy at a standstill and made a slide into deflation seem inevitable.

Euro zone GDP growth squeezed a meagre 0.2 per cent rise in the third quarter after a 0.1 per cent increase in the previous period. Without another major push, the economy could be bouncing along the bottom of recession for years.

The bloc’s largest economies, Germany and France, were spared an embarrassing plunge into triple-dip recession, but only by a small margin and they are not out of danger yet. Italy has not been so lucky. It is suffering its third recession in six years and deepening its economic plight in the process.

Some of the former euro zone crisis countries have fared better, especially Ireland, Spain and Greece, but this will be short-lived unless the Big Three core economies can achieve a growth orbit that is not at perpetual risk of decay.Stronger euro zone growth though is not going to happen unless policymakers do something much more substantive to fuel the recovery. The key building blocks for recovery – stronger consumption, increased investment, greater stock-building, more government spending and faster trade growth – have all been badly damaged and it is up to politicians to fix them.

Unfortunately, the political boffins seem stuck in denial, relying on a stubborn belief that recovery will spontaneously self-start at some stage soon. Considering the dismal economic backdrop at home and the wider international economy, the chances of that happening without official intervention are remote.

Without a plan for radical action soon, European Central Bank forecasts for 1.5 percent economic growth next year look highly improbable, and the chances of another recession look a much more likely possibility.

On the monetary side, the ECB needs to get its skates on for a speedy launch of quantitative easing (QE) – printing money to fund mass purchases of euro zone government bonds that will allow credit to be pumped into the economy to get the recovery’s vital life-signs working again.
The longer the ECB delays QE, the harder it will be contain recession and deflation once they break out again. In the long run, the cost of prevention will be much cheaper than the political cost of a possible future EMU break-up.

A return to expansive German fiscal policy could also boost demand for consumer and investment goods from abroad, lifting global growth prospects. Germany is, after all, the largest surplus economy in the world.


Putting the euro zone economy back on a clear growth trajectory will be an epic journey. Like every mission into the unknown, it needs brilliant organisation and enterprising ideas to help it on its way. Without it, the euro zone recovery could end up lost in space.

Reprinted courtesy of the South China Morning Post 17th November 2014

Wednesday, 12 November 2014

How EU withdrawal could turn Britain into an economic backwater


Britain's economic destiny hangs in the balance in the next few years. The country and the European Union remain on a collision course and, thanks to Prime Minister David Cameron's pledge for a public referendum on EU membership by 2017, a future British exit (Brexit) cannot be ruled out. A deepening gulf between Britain and Brussels and British voters' growing disenchantment towards Europe mean the chances of a messy divorce loom large.


The stakes are high. The fallout from an EU exit could wreak massive collateral damage on the British economy. Britain might not only end up marginalised outside Europe, but its growth prospects could be left badly scarred for decades to come.

The EU has done itself few favours in recent years. The spectacle of Europe's crisis-strewn economy and the image of the EU's bloated, over-regulating bureaucracy have alienated Britain's public opinion. With the British economy basking in 3 per cent-plus growth right now, it is no surprise that British eurosceptics argue the moment has arrived for the country to break free. They contend that greater national sovereignty is the best passport to faster growth.

They would be wrong to think that way. Britain's economic fortunes are completely intertwined with Europe's, no matter whether the country is in or out of the EU. Mutual economic dependency is so strong that if Britain plugs for an EU opt-out, the damage to both economies would be extensive and long-lasting.

Business with Europe is important to Britain. Export earnings to EU countries are worth up to £240 billion (HK$3 trillion) and support more than four million jobs in Britain. With business with the EU possibly worth up to 10 per cent of Britain's output, withdrawal from the EU would pose serious risks for the country.

Britain is a major beneficiary of foreign investment inflows. Since the early 1980s, multinational corporations have flocked to the country after former prime minister Margaret Thatcher opened Britain's doors to a European free enterprise zone. Companies from the United States and Asia see Britain as their gateway to Europe's single market. If Britain exits, there is a danger that these overseas firms would leave in droves, shifting their operations to Europe. The potential loss in production, investment and jobs would be catastrophic for Britain.

Britain's financial services sector would be under threat, too. London plays host to more than 250 international banks, accounting for a third of last year's £71 billion financial services trade surplus. Most US and Asian banks headquarter their European operations in London, giving them a passport to provide services across the EU. If Britain withdraws from Europe, many of these banks would abandon London and relocate to other EU financial centres to guarantee business continuity. The impact on London's financial industry and the fallout on construction and the property market in the southeast could be devastating for the economy.

In the long run, it would be a blow the British economy would struggle to recover from. It would be hard to imagine home-grown British companies rushing to fill the gap left by the exodus of businesses decamping to Europe. It would take years of government nurturing and massive national reinvestment to repair the damage. The dire state of Britain's public-sector finances would tend to rule that out. Britain could turn into an economic backwater.

Right now, Britain has the best of both worlds by being part of the EU, but not the euro and its associated economic risks. Dropping out from Europe's single market and relegation to membership of Europe's free trade association would see a key diminution of Britain's sphere of influence in European policymaking.


Britain's pro-independence politicians are gambling that the country can do better striking out on its own, a risky ploy in an uncertain world. Indeed, the EU needs vital reforms to put its economy back on the road to recovery.

In the long run, the better option for Britain may be to Fixit rather than Brexit.

Reprinted by courtesy of the South China Morning Post