Tuesday, 30 April 2013

Sound bites: Eurozone inflation at 1.2% a clarion call for immediate ECB rate cut

Eurozone inflation dropping to 1.2% is a shocking testament of policy failure by the ECB. Low and falling Eurozone inflation marks a clarion call for an immediate ECB rate cut this week. There should be no delay. Based on the ECB’s myopic inflation targeting, Eurozone monetary policy settings are far too tight. It is no wonder that the Eurozone economy has been steeped in recession for so long. Some parts of the Eurozone economy are even in deep danger of falling into depression without prescriptive policy action soon. The fact that inflation has fallen so sharply below the 2% target and that core inflation has been stuck below 2% for a decade, underlines the contingent risks ahead. Without a sharp reversal of policy across the board – monetary and fiscal – the survival of the Eurozone is at deep risk. The key is how long before disinflation (slowing inflation) turns into deflation (falling prices). Unless the ECB changes course soon, the Eurozone could soon be following Japan down the road to a decade of deflation and economic underperformance. Unless Eurozone policy starts to pull things together soon, the risks are the euro area could pull apart as growing economic and political strains set in.

There should be no hanging about this week. Draghi has already earmarked a rate cut soon and no better time to deploy it than this week. If there was ever a good reason for the ECB to cut at this week’s rate policy meeting, it would be a show of independence in the face of some blatant political interference from Germany’s Merkel to stop another ECB rate cut. Her argument for higher rates being appropriate for Germany at this juncture are completely out of place for a Eurozone that is in desperate need of extra stimulus right now. Her remarks will be counterproductive as they will probably forge a unity outside the German bloc for a quick and immediate cut.

A rate cut this week should only be the beginning. The ECB needs to follow through with unremitting waves of new liquidity - in conventional and unconventional form. The ECB needs to wake up to the exigencies of the debt crisis and extend the liquidity reaching the banks through to consumers and industry as much easier credit. The latest Eurozone money supply data underline that where domestic credit should be expanding, it is doing the opposite and contracting. An expansive credit policy combined with pro-growth fiscal stimulus is the only way to guarantee sustainable growth going forwards for the Eurozone. The ECB and Eurozone governments need to start working in tandem very quickly.

The weak inflation picture in the Eurozone highlights a major policy failure by the ECB. Inflation well below target and the economy in recession are the litmus tests that the ECB are not doing enough and it is time to start getting the recovery back into gear with another rate cut and more monetary intervention very soon.

















Monday, 29 April 2013

Sound bites: Eurozone economic confidence drops to 88.6 from 90.1 in April

Quite clearly, economic optimism has hit a brick wall in the Eurozone. The Eurozone debt crisis, the slowdown in the global economy and generally weak economic perceptions are joining forces to keep the euro area battened down by recession. The continuing fall in Eurozone economic confidence is paving the way for a deeper dip into negative growth territory given past trends. Weak economic confidence compounds the weak message evident in recent purchasing manager surveys and from the bleak stories coming out from individual Eurozone economies. From the troubled Eurozone countries to the core countries, the message is the same - only with a difference of degree. The recovery is going nowhere fast and the odds are that the Eurozone will extend its recession through 2013, possibly into 2014, without quick prescriptive action from Eurozone policymakers.

The components of demand underline the risks ahead. Unemployment is on the rise, real incomes are being squeezed hard and consumer sentiment is on the ropes. Weak perceptions about the economic picture, means output and investment intentions remain hard pressed in industry. The government sector remains a net drain on the economy, especially while the focus remains fixated on austerity. The export sector can only remain hampered by the global slowdown without a much weaker euro.

The policy environment must change fast. Monetary and fiscal policy need to work in concert, not in conflict. The ECB needs to cuts rates again this week. Cutting rates is only a small part of the story. The ECB needs to open up the monetary floodgates in size to refloat recovery expectations. It also needs to insure that consumer and companies can get much better access to better  credit. On the fiscal side, tough austerity needs to come to an end, with renewed focus on growth promotion policies instead. The tide is already starting to reject austerity in some countries, but the shift  needs to be much more universal and substantial. The euro needs to go lower to boost export hopes, so an official  whispering campaign for a more competitive currency could reap massive dividends for recovery prospects ahead.


Friday, 26 April 2013

Sound bites: weak Eurozone money supply trends stunt recovery prospects

The latest Eurozone money supply trends look really negative for the economy. Weak money supply trends continue to cast severe doubts on any chances of near term Eurozone recovery. The continuing contraction in Eurozone credit is now a major headache for Eurozone policymakers. A much better supply of private sector credit is absolutely vital if the Eurozone has any chance of getting back to sustainable recovery. An easy supply of credit is a vital life-blood of recovery and without it, the Eurozone recovery will be dead on arrival. The Eurozone banks should share a large part of the blame. The EU and the ECB  have re-capitalised the banks, but the banks are not fulfilling their part of the bargain. They are not passing through an adequate flow of new credit to consumers and industry. Without access to easier credit, the Eurozone recovery will wither on the vine.

Bank capital provisions may be part of the blame. But there is also a basic lack of confidence in the Eurozone economy. There is a lack of confidence in banks lending to borrowers. There is a lack of confidence on the part of borrowers to take up new credit given the deteriorating economic picture across the Eurozone. Consumer and business sentiment both remain in very bad shape and in need of a much greater lift.

This can be remedied. The EU and ECB can apply pressure to the banks to make more new credit available. The EU governments should also be able to boost economic confidence by rolling back the process of deep austerity causing the Eurozone downturn. With the tide already starting to turn from austerity towards easier budget policies in some Eurozone countries, there could be a way out of the malaise, if it can be backed up with easier money policies, including a more abundant supply of credit.


The ECB gave the following percentage changes in growth, seasonally adjusted:
                                         MAR    FEB       Prior
 M3 annual growth rate                   2.6    3.1       (3.1)
 M3 3-month moving avg 12-mo growth      3.0    3.4       (3.3)
 Annual total credit growth              0.0   -0.2      (-0.2)
 Annual credit growth private sector    -0.9   -1.1      (-1.2)
  -- of which loans                     -0.8   -0.8      (-0.9)
 Breakdown of Loans, pct annual growth rate:    
 Loans to households                     0.4    0.5       (0.5)
  -- consumer credit                    -3.4   -3.3      (-3.3)
  -- for home purchases                  1.3    1.4       (1.4)
 Loans to non-financial corporations    -1.3   -1.4      (-1.4)
 Monthly loan flow to firms (bln eur)      0      4         (2)


Thursday, 25 April 2013

Sound bites: UK avoids a 3rd recession in a row with a 0.3% qq rise in GDP

The government have been very, very lucky. They have avoided a third dip into recession by the skin of their teeth. There is nothing to celebrate over as the UK economy is not out of the woods yet. Without a change in the government’s tough austerity policies, the UK economy will be flirting with recession for years. The economy is still flat-lining and bouncing along bottom of recession. The global economy is slowing down, the Eurozone is in the process of a hard landing and UK domestic demand is in very poor shape. The outlook remains parlous.

UK policymaking has been working in opposite directions. While the Bank of England have been pressing down hard on the monetary accelerator, the government has jammed its foot hard down on the fiscal brake. What the UK economy has needed was four dimensional easing – easy rates, easy money, easy currency and easy fiscal policy. Budget cuts have neutralised a lot of the good work that the BOE have put in to get the recovery going again. It is no wonder that the economy is doing so badly. It is time for a u-turn in policy.

This message is already starting to sink in that the Eurozone must ditch austerity in favour of more pro-growth policies. This realisation is already beginning to surface in France, Spain, Italy and Portugal, with other countries likely to join the bandwagon as the EU gives its blessing to a change in austerity. Right now there is no alternative. Without a change in budget policy, the UK and the Eurozone will disappear down the sink-hole of even deeper recession

                            Q1 2013   Q4 2012   Q1 FORECAST
GDP AT MARKET PRICES
    Pct change q/q          0.3      -0.3        0.1
    Pct change y/y          0.6*      0.2        0.3


Wednesday, 24 April 2013

Sound bites: German IFO business confidence takes another dive in April

The sharp dip in Germany’s IFO index marks another nail in the coffin for stronger recovery this year. Germany’s economic fortunes are seeing a dramatic reversal of fortunes. The earlier bravado that Germany could stave off the Eurozone debt crisis is taking a tumble. Business confidence is taking a much gloomier view of the outlook ahead, based on the hard landing in the Eurozone and growing signs of slowdown in the global recovery. Based on what we have recently seen from the latest  IFO, ZEW and PMI business surveys, Germany will be very lucky to avoid a near term recession in the recent  two quarters. The economy is still flirting with recession this year. With so much of Germany’s economy dependent on the success of its export machine, the downturn in global prospects is bound to be reflected in a weaker outlook ahead. The Eurozone debt crisis is the main millstone around the German economy’s neck. While the economic picture continues to fester in the Eurozone, German growth will remain in the doldrums.

There seems little way out of the dilemma. Even while German unemployment is trending lower, German consumers always remain chronically unable to take up the slack. Weaker business confidence will pull down output and investment intentions in industry. The German government remains committed to a balanced budget. This needs to change. The only way out of the bind right now would be a much more munificent policy response by the ECB and Eurozone governments. The ECB looks like it is gearing up for another rate cut, but a quarter point ease is unlikely to make much difference to economic sentiment at this juncture. The ECB needs to open up its monetary coffers with greater abandon. This means it has to embark on an expansive quantitative easing path like its central bank peers – the US Fed, the BOJ and the BOE. In addition, the Eurozone needs to grow its way out of the debt crisis. Eurozone governments need to enact a u-turn on fiscal austerity in order to get the growth wheels in motion again. We are just starting to see early glimmers of a sea-change in austerity targets easing in France and Spain. We need to see more of this throughout the Eurozone in the next two years.

GERMAN IFO INDEX 104.4 IN APRIL VS REUTERS CONSENSUS FORECAST FOR 106.2 (MAY 106.7)
GERMAN CURRENT CONDITIONS INDEX 107.2 IN APRIL VS REUTERS CONSENSUS FORECAST FOR 109.5
GERMAN EXPECTATIONS INDEX 101.6 IN APRIL VS REUTERS CONSENSUS FORECAST FOR 103.0

 


Wednesday, 17 April 2013

Bank of England MPC minutes augur change

The tone of the MPC minutes suggest that the BOE may have entered into the semantics of transition. The UK might not be in recovery mode yet, but the intonation seems to suggest the economy is over the worst and out of casualty. The key is how much more QE medicine the economy needs to speed up the healing process to get the economy back on the road to fuller recovery. That debate probably awaits the arrival of incoming BOE governor Carney to see what he has in his monetary medicine bag. The argument posted by some members about the risk that more QE might pose to increased inflation risks is nothing more than a foil. In the current climate, the BOE’s inflation mandate is set aside while the risks of another dip into recession lurk in the forefront. King’s support for a further QE extension simply keeps the easing seat warm for Carney when he comes on board. For the moment, until Carney picks up the monetary reins, BOE policy should be expected to stay unchanged. But the markets should expect the policy sparks to fly as he starts to inject some new thinking into the equation for extra monetary stimulus ahead. Sterling might be off the hook for the moment, but downward pressure on the currency should be expected to come into full force once Carney’s new regime comes into effect. Carney will go overboard for faster recovery and sterling should take the strain over the future.

Tuesday, 16 April 2013

Sound bites: German ZEW economic sentiment collapses to 36.3 in April from 48.5 in March

The chickens are coming home to roost for economic confidence in Germany. This is being foreshadowed by a dramatic collapse in Germany’s ZEW index. The problems are starting to pile up for business, with the debt crisis in Cyprus, the Eurozone recession and the slowdown in China all taking a greater toll on sentiment. Last month, problems in Cyprus were only just beginning to make their mark, but this month the impact is much more apparent. In recent months, there has been a growing confidence that German business could shrug off the downside risks and rely upon faster export performance to pull the economy away from the rocks of recession. This looks increasingly misplaced as it will be impossible for Germany to decouple from the problems besetting the Eurozone and the increased risks of slowdown in the global economy.

This has important consequences for the German outlook. If business confidence is peaking, German companies are going to be far less optimistic about output intentions, new investment and new hiring. It means that domestic demand is not out of the woods and recession risks are still just as acute for Germany this year and possibly next. The deepening cost of the Cyprus bail-out underlines that there is more bad news to play out for the Eurozone debt crisis. While the Eurozone remains subsumed by recession forces, it’s not only an on-going risk for the troubled Eurozone periphery countries, but for the German economy as well. Germany’s economic fortunes are inextricably bound up with the fate of the Eurozone. Right now, this remains deeply troubled. The bottom line message for Eurozone policy is that greater economic stimulus is the only way forwards.

Budget policy must be much more forgiving given the dire economic outlook. Policy must switch from austerity towards pro-growth fiscal reflation. At the same time, the ECB needs to follow the same path adopted by the US Federal Reserve, the Bank of Japan and the Bank of England, to crank up the gears of recovery in the Eurozone with monetary reflation. At some stage, the ECB will have their epiphany and realise that the only way forward will be unremitting quantitative easing to get the Eurozone economy out of jail and onto a much firmer recovery track.

While the euro is enjoying a moment of relief the outlook remains deeply negative for the currency once the ECB opens up the monetary floodgates again. A return to USD1.20 territory looks increasingly obvious.